
Usually, yes. A private landlord or property manager may deny a rental applicant because of collection accounts, as long as the rule is written down, applied to every applicant the same way, and the applicant gets an adverse action notice when a screening report drove the decision. Collections can appear for seven years. This is information, not legal advice, current as of November 2026.
Is it legal to deny a rental application for collections?
Yes, in most of the US. Debt in collections is not a protected class under the Fair Housing Act, so a landlord may treat it as a sign of payment risk. Two limits apply. The criteria must be the same for everyone who applies, and a rule that sweeps in far more applicants of one protected group than another can still be challenged. Under 24 CFR 100.500, a practice can break the Act through its discriminatory effect even with no intent, unless it is backed by a legally sufficient justification. A narrow, written rule tied to rent risk is easier to justify than "no collections, ever".
How long do collections stay on a screening report?
Seven years. Under 15 U.S.C. 1681c(a)(4), a consumer report may not include accounts placed for collection or charged off that are more than seven years old. A bankruptcy can stay for ten. So a five-year-old unpaid phone bill can still show up, and a rule with no lookback reaches all of it. A rule that names a period is easier to apply the same way and easier to defend: for example, collections opened in the last three years.
Do all collections count the same?
They should not, and your written rule can say so. These are the lines most property managers draw:
- Unpaid rent or a landlord judgment: the closest match to the risk you are screening for.
- Utility collections: often counted, because they track the same monthly bill habit.
- Medical collections: often left out, and in some states kept off the report entirely.
- Paid or settled accounts: weighed less than open balances, or not at all.
- Small balances: a floor, such as ignoring anything under a set dollar amount, cuts denials over a forgotten bill.
Can a landlord deny for medical debt?
It depends on the state. California Civil Code section 1785.27 bars anyone from furnishing medical debt to a credit reporting agency, so it should not reach a California screening report at all. The federal rule that would have removed medical debt from credit reports nationwide never took hold: a federal court in Texas vacated it on July 11, 2025. Outside states with their own law, medical collections can still appear, and leaving them out of your criteria is the safer choice.
Is a bigger deposit instead of a denial still an adverse action?
Yes. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says an adverse action includes requiring a co-signer, a larger deposit or higher rent than other applicants, not only a denial. The notice must name the screening company with its address and phone number, explain the right to a free copy of the report within 60 days, and explain the right to dispute errors. The company generally has 30 days to investigate, sometimes 45. Any deposit must also stay under your state's cap; see security deposit limits by state and province.
Where does this go wrong in practice?
At the phone screen and the showing, before any report is pulled. A leasing agent tells one caller "we don't take collections" and says nothing to the next. Now the rule is applied unevenly, and there is no record of who heard what. Put the rule in the listing or the application criteria, quote it the same way to every prospect, and decide only after the report.
LetHub is AI leasing software for property managers: it answers rental inquiries by text, chat, email and phone in about 30 seconds, day and night, qualifies renters, books tours and runs ID-verified self-showings. It quotes your written criteria the same way to every prospect, in writing.
FAQ
Can a landlord deny for one small collection account?
Legally, yes, if the written rule says so and is applied to everyone. Many managers set a dollar floor or count only open balances, because a single forgotten bill says little about whether rent gets paid.
What if the collection on the report is wrong?
The applicant can dispute it with the screening company and the company that reported it. A landlord may hold the unit for a set time while the dispute runs, as long as the same courtesy is offered to every applicant.
Does paying off a collection help?
Often. A paid account can stay on the report for the rest of its seven years, but many written criteria count only unpaid balances. Ask the property manager what their rule says. Our post on denying an applicant for bankruptcy covers the longer lookback.
To see how an AI leasing agent applies the same written criteria to every prospect, book a demo.


