
No, not because of the diagnosis. Under the federal Fair Housing Act a mental illness that substantially limits a major life activity is a disability, and a landlord may not refuse to rent because of it. A denial is lawful only when objective evidence of current conduct shows a direct threat to others or their property. This is information, not legal advice.
Is a mental illness a disability under the Fair Housing Act?
Usually, yes. 42 U.S.C. 3602(h) defines the protected class (the statute says "handicap") as a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, a record of one, or being regarded as having one. Depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, PTSD and anxiety disorders can all qualify. The "regarded as" part matters most in leasing: a landlord who turns someone away because they seem unwell is covered even if no diagnosis exists. Section 3604(f)(1) bars refusing to rent on that basis.
When can a landlord deny an applicant as a direct threat?
Rarely, and only on evidence. Section 3604(f)(9) says the Act does not require renting to someone whose tenancy "would constitute a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals" or would cause substantial physical damage to others' property. The 2004 HUD and Justice Department Joint Statement on reasonable accommodations sets the test. The decision must rest on an individualized assessment and reliable objective evidence, such as current conduct or a recent history of overt acts, and it must weigh:
- The nature, duration and severity of the risk.
- The probability that injury will actually occur.
- Whether a reasonable accommodation would remove the threat.
The statement says exclusion based on "fear, speculation, or stereotype" is not allowed, and a provider must consider whether treatment since the incident has removed the risk.
What can a landlord ask an applicant about mental health?
Nothing about the condition itself. 24 CFR 100.202(c) bars asking whether an applicant has a disability or how severe it is. It allows a short list of questions, as long as every applicant is asked them:
- Whether the applicant can meet the requirements of the tenancy, such as paying rent and following the lease.
- Whether the applicant currently uses illegal drugs.
- Whether the applicant has been convicted of making or selling illegal drugs.
Our post on whether a landlord can ask about a disability covers the wording.
How should a property manager screen without crossing the line?
Screen conduct, not conditions. Use the same written criteria for everyone: income, rental history, landlord references and any recent lease violations. If a reference reports damage or threats, judge that conduct and its date the same way you would for any applicant. If an applicant explains that a past problem was tied to an illness now treated, that is a reasonable accommodation request, and it deserves a written answer. See how to handle a reasonable accommodation request.
This matters because disability is where complaints concentrate. The National Fair Housing Alliance's 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report found disability made up 54.6 percent of fair housing complaints in 2024.
LetHub is AI leasing software for property managers: it answers rental inquiries by text, chat, email and phone in about 30 seconds, day and night, qualifies renters, books tours and runs ID-verified self-showings. It asks every prospect the same questions from your written criteria and never asks about health.
FAQ
Can a landlord deny someone because of a past psychiatric hospitalization?
No. A record of an impairment is itself protected under 42 U.S.C. 3602(h). A past hospitalization is not evidence of a current direct threat.
Can a landlord deny for a criminal record linked to a mental illness?
A landlord can apply written criminal history criteria the same way to everyone. If the applicant asks for an exception because the conduct was tied to an illness now treated, that request has to be considered individually.
What about a current tenant whose behavior worries neighbors?
Act on specific conduct that breaks the lease, document it, and consider whether an accommodation would solve the problem before moving to termination. A diagnosis alone is never grounds to end a tenancy.
To see how an AI leasing agent asks every prospect the same questions, book a demo.


